I would honestly suggest that you take the time to consider your feelings regarding Yahweh. He likely is attempting to speak to you, but in some ways, it can seem difficult for many people to believe that.
We are all overwhelmed by the constant presence of Abrahamic beliefs in Western culture, and often to a point that we begin to ignore it.
It slowly becomes watered down.
An example would be that we know that, in Christianity, Christ died for humanity. However, the repeated message becomes so ‘clean’ to us that we don’t really think of how agonizing death by crucifixion is. We don’t imagine him sweaty, bloody, and moaning for his Father.
When you truly start to ponder such details, it can make one sick with the realizations.
Don’t have doubt that Yahweh would love to have you as his child. He would love to cover you in his grace. There is no reason to doubt that.
The only deciding factor is how you would feel about ceasing to worship the Theoi. They share the same qualifying factor as Yahweh; they will not be worshiped as lesser than another god.